NEM 3.0, explained for Bay Area homeowners
What changed in April 2023, what it did to export credits, and why storage now leads.
In this article
- NEM 3.0, formally the Net Billing Tariff, applies to new PG&E, SCE and SDG&E solar customers who applied to interconnect on or after April 15, 2023.
- Export credits fell sharply. Power you send to the grid is now valued at the utility's avoided cost, which changes by hour and is far below the retail rate most of the year.
- Self-use is the new goal. A battery stores midday surplus for the 4 to 9pm peak, which is why most new systems are designed battery first.
For more than a decade, California's net metering made rooftop solar simple: every kilowatt-hour your panels sent to the grid earned roughly what you paid for one. In December 2022 the California Public Utilities Commission voted to replace that system for new customers, and the change took effect in April 2023. Solar still works under the new rules. It just works differently, and the design has to follow.
How net metering worked before
Under NEM 1 and NEM 2, your meter effectively ran backwards when you exported. Surplus at noon offset power you bought at night, close to one for one at retail value. That made the grid act like a free battery, so the best design was simply the biggest array the roof and budget allowed.
What NEM 3.0 changed
The new Net Billing Tariff pays for exports based on the utility's avoided cost: what that energy is worth to the grid at the moment you send it. Those values change by hour and month. Midday exports, when the grid is full of solar, earn very little. Late summer evenings, when demand is high and solar is fading, earn much more. On average, export credits dropped by roughly three quarters compared with NEM 2.
New customers also move to an electrification time-of-use rate, where power costs most during the late afternoon and evening peak. Under PG&E's plans, that peak runs from 4 to 9pm every day.
| Topic | NEM 2 | NEM 3.0 (Net Billing Tariff) |
|---|---|---|
| Applies to | Customers who applied before April 15, 2023 | New customers from April 15, 2023 |
| Export credit | Close to the retail rate | Avoided cost, varies by hour and month |
| Midday exports | Valuable | Worth little most of the year |
| Best design | Largest array that fits | Panels sized to your use, plus a battery |
| Role of a battery | Backup, optional | Core of the savings |
Who it applies to
NEM 3.0 applies to customers of PG&E, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric who submitted a complete interconnection application on or after April 15, 2023. Most Bay Area homes are PG&E customers, including those whose generation comes from a community choice provider such as CleanPowerSF, MCE, Ava Community Energy, Peninsula Clean Energy or Silicon Valley Clean Energy.
Homes that went solar earlier keep their NEM 1 or NEM 2 plan for 20 years from their original interconnection date. Adding a battery to an existing system generally does not end that plan, as long as the solar array itself is not expanded. Cities with their own municipal utility, such as Palo Alto and Alameda, set their own rules.
Already on NEM 2? Storage can add backup power and peak savings without giving up your plan. Confirm your plan's rules with your utility before you change anything on the roof.
How it changes the design
Under NEM 3.0, the most valuable solar is the solar you use yourself. That changes three things.
- Batteries move to the center. A battery charges from midday surplus and powers the house through the 4 to 9pm peak, so you buy little or nothing at the highest rate.
- Arrays are sized to use, not roof space. Extra panels that only export at noon add little value. The right size comes from your interval data.
- Orientation matters more. West-facing panels that produce later in the day can be worth more than their total output suggests.
A simple example
Picture a sunny weekday. The panels make more than the house needs from late morning to mid-afternoon. Without a battery, that surplus goes to the grid for a small credit, and the house buys peak-priced power from 4 to 9pm. With a battery, the surplus charges the battery instead, and the battery runs the house through the evening. Same panels, same sunshine, much better value per kilowatt-hour.
See the moment-by-moment version in our home battery diagram, and how long that stored energy lasts in how long a solar battery can power a house.
What does NEM 3.0 mean for your bill?
We model it with your real PG&E usage and rate plan.
Before you sign a NEM 3.0 proposal
- Does it model savings on the NEM 3.0 export values and the rate plan you will actually be on?
- Was it sized from 12 months of your interval data, or from a single bill?
- Does it show how much of your evening peak the battery covers?
- If you are on NEM 1 or NEM 2 today, does it explain how the work keeps your plan?
Watch for old math. A proposal that assumes every exported kilowatt-hour earns the retail rate is using pre-2023 rules. Ask how exports are valued.